Comedy Shows NYC Thanksgiving Week: A Comedian's Game Plan
Planning comedy shows in NYC over Thanksgiving week? A working comedian on which nights to book, what the Comedy Cellar costs, and club etiquette.
By Richie Redding · · 5 min read
If your family is coming to New York for Thanksgiving, sooner or later someone will ask what there is to do after dinner. Booking comedy shows in NYC is one of the easiest answers, as long as you pick the right night. Thanksgiving falls on Thursday, November 26 this year, and the clubs don't treat every night of that week the same way.
I'm a stand-up comedian, and I'm on stage in these rooms during the holiday week. So here's the plan I'd give a friend: which nights to book, what it costs, and how to keep your uncle from becoming part of the act.
Quick timing note: the New York Comedy Festival wrapped on November 15. It ran ten days across all five boroughs, and its 22nd year had more than 100 shows. The big festival bookings are done. What's left over Thanksgiving week is regular club comedy, and that's the good stuff anyway.
Are comedy shows in NYC open on Thanksgiving?
Some are, some aren't, and the honest answer is to check the calendar for the exact night you want.
When I looked at New York Comedy Club's November calendar this week, it had shows at all three of its rooms (Midtown on East 24th Street, the East Village on East 4th Street, and the Upper West Side on West 78th) on the Wednesday before Thanksgiving and all through Black Friday weekend. It didn't list any shows on Thanksgiving night itself. Calendars change, so look again before you plan around it.
The Comedy Cellar posts a separate holiday price on its site: "Holidays & Special Events: $25.00." If you're set on a show on the holiday itself, start there and check the lineup page for that date.
My advice is to skip Thursday. You'll be full, someone will want to watch football, and the next three nights are packed with shows.
The best nights for comedy over Thanksgiving weekend
Here's how I'd rank the week, from the comic's side of the stage.
Wednesday, November 25
In my opinion, the night before Thanksgiving is one of the best crowds of the year. Everybody's home, nobody has work tomorrow, and the crowd is ready. New York Comedy Club's calendar has a full Wednesday slate, including Story Warz with Big Jay Oakerson and Luis J. Gomez in Midtown and Good Eggs (presented by Mark Normand, Gary Vider and Matt Ruby) in the East Village. At the Cellar, Wednesday is still on the $15 weekday price.
Black Friday, November 27
The best night for a family group. You've all had a day to recover. New York Comedy Club has Friday showcases running from 6:00 p.m. into late night across its three rooms. The Cellar is at its $25 weekend price, and you should book early.
Saturday, November 28
It's the busiest night and the easiest to sell out. If you've got kids in their twenties or a group that likes a late show, this is your night. New York Comedy Club has a 4:00 p.m. Upper West Side show, which works nicely if you're near the Museum of Natural History during the day.
Sunday, November 29
It's the sleeper pick. The Cellar runs a 1:30 p.m. show at its MacDougal Street room on Sundays, and Sunday tickets are $18. A matinee before somebody catches a train home is about as civilized as New York comedy gets.
What does the Comedy Cellar cost?
The Comedy Cellar's own site lays it out. In New York, shows are $15 Monday through Wednesday (New Joke Night is $10), $18 on Thursday and Sunday, and $25 on Friday, Saturday, holidays and special events. On top of that there's a two-item minimum per person, "Food or Drink or bottle of water."
So for a family of four on Black Friday, figure $100 in tickets plus eight items. Water counts, which matters if Grandma doesn't drink.
Check which room is on your ticket, too. The Cellar runs shows at the original MacDougal Street room, the Village Underground and the Fat Black Pussycat. They're all a short walk apart in Greenwich Village. That's also where I'll be the Tuesday and Wednesday before Thanksgiving, on the Fat Black Pussycat side.
If you want more on the clubs themselves, I wrote up the best comedy clubs in NYC last week, with addresses, prices and the vibe of each room.
What to expect at a comedy club (a guide for the relatives)
Most of your family probably hasn't been to a New York club. Here's what to tell them in the cab.
- It's a showcase. You'll usually see several comics doing shorter sets, not one person for 90 minutes. If you don't love one, the next one is coming in ten minutes.
- It's tight in there. Time Out gave the Cellar five stars and also warned, "Claustrophobes, beware." They're right, so don't bring the giant shopping bags from Herald Square.
- Phones away. Time Out mentions the Cellar's "strict no-phone policy." Comics are working on jokes, and nothing kills a room like a glowing screen in the second row.
- Sit where they put you. The front row might get talked to. That's the deal. Smile, answer the question, and you'll be the hero of the group text.
- Don't heckle. Your cousin who is "the funny one" at Thanksgiving is not the funny one here. Let the professionals carry it.
- Laugh out loud. A crowd that laughs gets a better show. Comics feed off it, and holiday weekend rooms can get loud in the best way.
Holiday crowds are mixed, with locals, visitors and college kids home for the week in the same room. Club comics are built for that. It's why I think a night of regular club comedy is a safer bet for a family group than gambling on one famous name.
See me live over Thanksgiving week
If you're in town and want to see me, my dates for Thanksgiving week and beyond are on my See Me Live list. You'll also find more guides like this one under NYC comedy on the blog.
And if a great Black Friday show leaves you thinking your company's holiday party could use a host who can work a room like that, that's exactly what I do as a corporate event emcee.
Frequently asked questions
- Are comedy clubs in NYC open on Thanksgiving?
- It depends on the club, so check each calendar. New York Comedy Club's November calendar listed shows at all three of its Manhattan rooms on the Wednesday before Thanksgiving and on Black Friday, but none on Thanksgiving night when I checked. The Comedy Cellar lists a separate $25 holiday price on its site.
- How much are Comedy Cellar tickets over Thanksgiving weekend?
- The Comedy Cellar's site lists $15 shows Monday through Wednesday, $18 on Thursday and Sunday, and $25 on Friday, Saturday, holidays and special events. Every guest also has a two-item minimum, which can be food, a drink or a bottle of water. Book ahead for Black Friday and Saturday.
- What should I expect at a comedy club in New York?
- Expect a showcase of several comics doing short sets, tight seating, and a food or drink minimum on top of the ticket. Phones stay in your pocket. Time Out notes the Comedy Cellar has a strict no-phone policy. Arrive early, sit where the staff puts you, and laugh out loud.
Sources



