Approachable Leadership: Why 43% of CEOs Fear Empathy
Approachable leadership scares CEOs: 43% fear losing respect if they show empathy, a new report says. A comedian on why they have it backward.
By Richie Redding · · 4 min read
A new survey asked 300 top executives how they feel about leading with empathy, and a lot of them are scared of it. According to Businessolver's 2026 State of Workplace Empathy report, 43% of CEOs fear losing respect if they show empathy at work. That's a story about approachable leadership, and about how many people at the top still think being approachable costs them something.
I've spent more than 20 years on stage, and now a good chunk of my week goes to leadership workshops. So I read this the way a comic reads a room that won't laugh: first I check what I did walking out there.
If you manage people, this matters because your team is doing the same math your CEO is, from the other side of the desk.
What did the Businessolver report find?
Businessolver, a benefits technology company, surveyed 300 C-suite leaders across six industries and a separate group of 1,000 employees. HR Dive covered the executive report on Nov. 12, and People Matters ran its own write-up on Nov. 4. A few numbers jumped out at me.
- According to People Matters, 99% of CEOs and 88% of CHROs believe empathy contributes to business results.
- In the same report, 59% of CEOs and 51% of CHROs or chief people officers expect their decisions to be challenged when they lead with empathy.
- 61% of executives say showing empathy consistently is hard in their day-to-day work.
- In toxic workplace cultures, 78% of executives fear losing respect for showing empathy. In non-toxic cultures, it's 14%.
So almost everyone at the top agrees empathy pays off, and a big share of them are still afraid to do it. Marcy Klipfel, Businessolver's chief engagement officer, said, in the People Matters write-up, "Executives have overwhelmingly accepted the business case for empathy." They've accepted it on paper, anyway. The fear numbers say plenty of them still hesitate to show it at work.
There's a darker number in there too. HR Dive reports that 70% of C-suite leaders in toxic cultures report significant financial growth, compared with 36% in non-toxic cultures. Businessolver's own framing of that, on its report page, is a question: "Are toxic companies out-performing or just out-pacing the consequences?" I'd bet on the second one, and I'm a comedian, not an economist.
Why do CEOs think approachable leadership looks weak?
My theory is that leaders who are afraid of empathy picture something soft: saying yes to everybody, never firing anyone, hugging it out in the parking lot. Approachable leadership looks a lot more like good stand-up. On stage, the comics I respect most are the ones who notice the guy checking his phone in the third row and adjust before he's gone. Paying attention is what makes an audience trust you enough to follow you somewhere weird.
Leading a team works the same way. When you listen, admit you were wrong about the plan and then make the hard call anyway, people tend to respect you more, because they've watched you pay attention first.
The 78% versus 14% split makes sense to me too. If the place runs on intimidation, being approachable feels dangerous because everyone around you is keeping score, and getting colder only teaches the next layer of managers to keep score too.
How to build trust with your team when you're scared it'll cost you
Employees are clear about what they want. In the employee half of the survey, two-thirds said they would accept lower pay to work for a more empathetic employer. Your people would take a pay cut to get what some CEOs are afraid to give away for free.
Businessolver's president and CEO, Jon Shanahan, told HR Dive: "Performance and empathy were never mutually exclusive." I agree, and I'd add that approachability is mostly habits, small ones, done on purpose. Here's where I'd start tomorrow:
- Go first with a mistake. Tell your team about something you got wrong this month, plainly, before anyone asks. It gives everyone else permission to do the same, and that's where psychological safety at work actually starts.
- Ask one question before you decide. Before a call that affects the team, ask the person closest to the work what you're missing. Then decide. You still made the decision. You just made it with better information.
- Laugh at yourself. A self-deprecating line lowers the temperature in a meeting faster than anything I know. Aim the joke at the boss, never down the org chart.
- Don't overdo the comedy. Tony Kong, a researcher at CU Boulder's Leeds School of Business, warned in a Q&A with CU Boulder Today that "frequent jokes from bosses can stress employees, who may fake laughter constantly." If people are laughing out of duty, you've made things worse.
- Say what you heard. When someone pushes back, repeat their point back in one sentence before you answer. It costs ten seconds and tells them they got through.
You keep every bit of your authority doing any of this. Your team just finds out you know they're in the room.
Where humor in leadership fits
Humor is one of the fastest ways to show you're approachable, and one of the fastest ways to show you're not, depending on who the joke lands on. In that same CU Boulder Q&A, Kong said humor can help leaders "build trust, strengthen teams and even elevate status if used wisely." The "if used wisely" part is doing a lot of work in that sentence.
I've written about leaders getting this half right, like when Sam Altman turned the joke on himself but used it as the whole answer, and about how funny job ads can make employers look less fair. Both times, the joke worked only as well as the trust behind it.
If your CEO is one of the 43% who worry empathy will cost them respect, that's exactly the gap we work on in our leadership workshops on humor and trust. You can read more stories like this one in our humor in leadership posts.
Your team is already deciding whether you're approachable. Let's make sure they get the right answer.
Frequently asked questions
- Why are CEOs afraid to show empathy at work?
- In Businessolver's 2026 executive survey of 300 C-suite leaders, 43% of CEOs said they fear losing respect if they show empathy, and 59% expect their decisions to be challenged when they lead with it. Many leaders treat being approachable as a sign of weakness, even though almost all of them say empathy helps business results.
- What is approachable leadership?
- Approachable leadership means people on your team feel safe bringing you bad news, questions and ideas without worrying about how you'll react. It shows up in small habits: asking before deciding, admitting mistakes, listening without interrupting and being easy to talk to. It doesn't mean giving up authority or avoiding hard calls.
- Does showing empathy make a leader look weak?
- Leaders worry it will, but employees see it differently. In Businessolver's survey of 1,000 employees, two-thirds said they would accept lower pay to work for a more empathetic employer. Respect tends to come from being fair and consistent. A leader who listens and still makes the hard call usually earns more of it.
Sources
- HR Dive: Many executives say they are worried about leading with empathy (Nov. 12, 2026)
- People Matters: CEOs and CHROs fear losing authority by leading with empathy? Study finds (Nov. 4, 2026)
- Businessolver: 2026 State of Workplace Empathy Executive Report
- CU Boulder Today: Funny business: Humor scholars on whether jokes help or hurt at work (Mar. 23, 2026)


